I sat down on Sunday night to watch Underbelly: Razor with a sense of impending dread. Much like when you attend a school band concert. You really hope it’s going to be good, but as the opening bars of Bohemian Rhapsody are squeaked out by the trumpets, you know you’re in for a long night.

And that was pretty much how it was on Sunday night. I’m not going to go on about the gratuitous sex, tits and arse, because it is part of the Underbelly franchise and that’s what they do. But I was hoping that they would at least hold true to the essence of the story and not deprive the women of the power, business acumen and toughness they undoubtedly had.

Kate Leigh & Tilly Devine, 1948

I first came across the story of Kate Leigh and Tilly Devine at the  Sydney Justice and Police Museum’s Femme Fatale exhibition a couple of years ago. It was a fascinating, bloody and sordid tale of prostitution, sly grog and murder. The Kingpins of the Sydney Crime World for well over a decade from the mid 1920’s were Kate Leigh and Tilly Devine.

Frog Hollow, Surry Hills

A few months later I joined a Walking Tour of Surry Hills and Darlinghurst that focused on the history of the area, particularly the lifelong rivalry between these two women. Surry Hills and Darlinghurst are now gentrified inner city suburbs of Sydney. Cafes, vintage boutiques, restaurants, bars and stylish furniture shops sit amongst the terrace houses and laneways. But back in the first half of the 20th century they were slums housing the working poor, bubonic plague and the razor gangs of the 1920s and 1930s.

Frog Hollow now - there were once 89 houses squeezed onto this block of land

According to the TV series Razor, Kate Leigh and Tilly Devine were glamorous crooks surrounded by men who did the hard graft and in Tilly’s case, it was her husband who ran the show. I’m not suggesting these women were standout role models, but the fact is they were both very astute business women, vicious and ruthless who held extraordinary power within Sydney society.

Tilly Devine's mug shot, 1925, aged 26

They were never outwitted or played for fools by standover man and gangster, Norm Bruhn. And he certainly didn’t come up with the idea of using a razor sitting in a barber’s chair in 1927.  Tilly Devine had already served time at Long Bay Gaol for slashing a man’s face with a razor in 1925. And it had been the weapon of choice for petty criminals and muggers for some time.

Tilly Devine, 1929 aged 30

It was Tilly Devine who realised that the law specifically stipulating that men couldn’t run brothels, meant that a woman was immune from prosecution. She bank-rolled her first brothel from the money she had saved as a working prostitute and went on to build a network of the most lucrative and well run brothels Sydney has ever seen.

Kate Leigh, mug shot, 1930, aged 49

Kate Leigh operated a sly grog business for 35 years. At the height of her career, she ran twenty-six outlets. She was one Sydney’s wealthiest citizens. She also traded in stolen goods and was a major supplier of cocaine.

Kate Leigh

Kate and Tilly held onto their power through brute force and intimidation. Kate shot dead a man in 1930, but was acquitted on the grounds of self-defense. They were both bare knuckle street brawlers and used a razor or a gun if they needed to. The Razor Gang wars were instigated by these two women, who used the men in their employ to protect their business empires.

Like Al Capone, the notorious Chicago gangster, Kate Leigh and Tilly Devine were eventually brought to justice by the Tax Department. They both died in abject poverty.

Nellie Cameron's mug shot, 1930, aged 21

And as for prostitute Nellie Cameron, she never worked for Tilly Devine. She didn’t need to. She may have been from a middle class family, but she was a thief and a drug-runner with strong criminal contacts and could defend her patch on the corner of William and Palmer St.s without any help. Nellie Cameron committed suicide in her Darlinghurst apartment at the age of 41.

Of course, the Underbelly series has never pretended to be a documentary, they’re made to be entertaining. But why did they dilute these incredibly strong women? They certainly haven’t done that with the male protagonists in this, or any of the other seasons in the series. Did they think the public wouldn’t accept that women were capable of such violence or have the ability to hold on to the businesses they built for such a long period of time? Or is it just more titillating to reduce them to scantily clad, often naked, women for the entertainment of the viewing public?

Razor - Larry Writer

The series is based on the book Razor, by Larry Writer. It’s a great read and an extraordinary insight to a fascinating time in Australia’s history.

I also obtained images from the Razorhurst website and the book, Femme Fatale, published by the Historic Houses Trust of NSW.


10 thoughts on “Razored

  1. Thanks very much for the review Jennifer. You just saved me a few hours. I was looking so forward to watching it. I suppose the “Rolling in the Deep” soundtrack by Adele in the promo was always going to suck us all in. I recorded it but won’t bother watching it now. I’d rather have a read of the book, which I’ll get soon.

    Thanks for the history lesson! I enjoyed it. That walking tour would be so interesting.

    Anne xx

  2. I was really disappointed in Underbelly: Razor too. I read about Tilly and Kate in an article a year or so ago and found the story fascinating. The TV series could have been so great but it just isn’t what it could be. Thanks for sharing the book, I’d love to have a read.

    Visiting from the Rewind

  3. I missed the first episode of Razor so decided not to try to ‘catch up’. Sounds like my time would be better spent reading the book! Thanks for the recommendation and interesting history lesson. Cheers for joining the Weekend Rewind. Always a pleasure! x

  4. I’ve been watching the series and whilst it’s entertaining it does annoy me the way the producers twist history. You’re right the actual version is far more fascinating than the one presented on TV.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s